Aug 212010
 

There are a number of factors which influence a prints price. One of those being the nature of the signature on the print. With Toshi Yoshida there are three variants of his ‘western style’ signature found on nearly all his prints which is the topic for this article. There is a fourth variant of his signature, that being pencil signed in Japanese kanji which appears on his prints from the 1980′s (eg. Birds of the Seasons and the Friendly Garden triptych) produced for the Franklin Mint.

Posthumous Prints: Those prints made after Toshi Yoshida’s death by the Yoshida family/studio. The artists signature is applied to the print with a stamp. These are generally the cheapest prints to buy but the quality is still very high and you are still getting a hand-made product.

Raised Seal Prints: These are prints made towards the end of his lifetime when still supervising print production at the studio but was too weak to hand sign the prints. As with posthumous prints the artists signature is applied to the print and a stamped embossed seal is also added to the print (typically in the bottom right margin). Price-wise these prints tend to sit between the posthumous and hand-signed print prices.

Pencil Signed Prints: These are lifetime prints hand signed in pencil by the artist himself and tend to be the most expensive.

When buying a print it’s important to know (among other factors) whether the print is pencil signed, a raised seal edition or a posthumous edition.

Signature example – Posthumous print.

Toshi Yoshida Posthumous Example Toshi Yoshida signature comparison

The easiest way to spot a posthumous print is by viewing the prints verso. If there are Japanese kanji characters in the verso margin then it’s a posthumous print. You don’t always get a chance to see a prints verso (as it may be framed or you may be buying/bidding online) but you can also tell by checking the artists signature on the print.

My personal rules to test for a stamped/posthumous signature are…
if the last three characters show
(a) a gap between the ‘i’ and the ‘d’.
(b) the ‘d’ sits higher that the ‘i’ and the ‘a’.
(c) the loop of the ‘a’ is closed.
It’s not guaranteed, but if the above tests are true then it’s very likely to be a stamped signature print.

Signature example – Raised seal print.

Toshi Yoshida Raised Seal Example Toshi Yoshida signature comparison

As can be seen above the signature matches the stamped/posthumous one and there is an embossed seal to the right of the signature so this is a lifetime raised seal print.

Signature example – Pencil signed print.

Toshi Yoshida Pencil Signed Example Toshi Yoshida signature comparison

Pencil signed prints do not have stamped kanji characters on the verso and do not have an embossed image beside the signature. Often the loop of the ‘a’ is open. The signature will not match those on the posthumous prints however there is no guarantee that this is always the case. I have seen one or two that are close but I suspect that the carving of the signature to make the stamp probably made it unique.

 August 21, 2010  Posted by at 8:00 am General, Toshi Yoshida Tagged with: ,  Add comments

  8 Responses to “Toshi Yoshida signature comparison”

  1.  

    If I am looking at a Toshi Yoshida “Bamboo of the Friendly Garden” and it has Franklin int stamp on the back – is that necessarily mean it is original Kanji signature. It is framed and I cannot look at the verso. It says Franklin Mint 1980 on the label on the back. What’s it worth unframed.
    Thanks, sid

    •  

      Hello Sid,
      I believe that the woodblock prints in the Toshi Yoshida Friendly Garden series were only produced as lifetime print/s.

      Pricing’s really difficult to give, for example, I’ve seen the set of three prints (framed) for anywhere from $247USD (on ebay) to around $1600USD (web gallery). Generally a collector would want the print framed in the original teak frame.

      An original framed Friendly Garden Pine woodblock print sold recently on ebay sold for $300USD earlier this month.
      I can’t recall seeing an unframed print from the series being sold so have no guide to what an unframed print would be worth.
      Regards, Mike.

  2.  

    The Japaneese kanji signature – would that draw the same higher price as the pencil signed? I have all 3 Friendly Garden prints collecting dust and thought I’d sell them.

    Thanks,
    - Don

    •  

      The Friendly Garden series from 1980 was a lifetime edition so it’s comparable to the pencil signed prints. The only lifetime prints that are worth less than a pencil signed print are the raised seal edition prints which bear a stamped Toshi Yoshida signature and an embossed/raised seal and were produced whilst he was alive but to ill to hand sign prints.

  3.  

    I have a Toshi Yoshida ‘Hummingbird and Fushia’ purchased approx. 1982 with pencil signature. Back of frame reads – Humming birds, self carved, self printed.

    I am looking to sell it. Would you be able to give me a rough valuation.

    Kind regards,
    Liz

    •  

      Hi Liz,
      I’m not a valuer so can’t give you a valuation. To have your woodblock print valued you’d need to contact a local auction house or appraiser/valuer. I can tell you however that the very few auction records I can see list this woodblock print selling at prices from $200USD (way to cheap!) to $500USD. The most recent one I saw – framed – was July last year for $256USD.

      An auction house or professional appraiser would have access to much more sales history data than I can see.

      The only copy of this woodlbock print I could find for sale after doing a quick search is $800USD and its been available for a very long time.

      Personally if I was selling my copy – never framed and in very good condition – on eBay I’d try setting my starting price at $350 hoping to get more, but you never know who’s out there to bid.

      Regards, Mike.

  4.  

    I have a pencil signed in Japanese, framed in I think teakwood PINE TREE OF THE FRIENDLY GARDEN by TOSHI YOSHIDA. CIRCA 1980 FRANKLIN MINT. It has a small stain on right bottom corner on raw silk and I read I could clean it with mild soap and water. I am not a professional so would rather not touch it, due to wanting to sell it. Do you know of any places that buy this type of art in southern Calif. USA.

    Thank You
    Linda M.

 Leave a Reply

(required)

(required)

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>